Mt.Tom's Homemade Ice Cream

We love this place. First you walk in and immediately smell the fresh waffle cones baking and it smells amazing. They have a large selection of flavors and there is something new all the time, you can even suggest your dream flavor! They pack the pints full, I mean full! Hundreds of what we called Penny candy to choose from as well as handmade chocolate and treats. You can sample what u like and they r happy to let you. 😊

I’ve got a severe dairy allergy so I ordered the vegan coffee Oreo ice cream. The server also sanitized the spoon and it looks like the vegan ice cream is kept separately. I’m very careful about going out to eat because of cross contamination and this was awesome because it was my first time having ice cream at a restaurant!

Very delicious chocolate peanut butter cup ice cream. We also tried the maple walnut which was very rich and creamy. I love that their ice cream is homemade and that they use chocolate base instead of vanilla for the peanut butter cups. Yummy!

I never write reviews, but when looking for “best of” anything, I value those who do. This is hands-down, the best ice cream in the valley (potentially anywhere?) The ice cream is perfectly balanced in flavor, and not overly sweet with a variety of salty/sweet combinations. The waffle cones are perfection. The smell of the cones alone is worth a trip. Can’t eat any other ice cream again, thanks to this place.

A good variety of flavors, though I wasn't hugely impressed with my own choices.

The coconut I had was kinda marshmallowy, which I do not like at all. The salted butter caramel was better, but too salty or too plain, depending on where I bit in. My waffle cone was good and fresh, though (made right there). I think the serving size could have been better as well - just look how lost my ice cream looks in the cone.

That said, my wife (maple walnut with cashew turtle) and son (peppermint stick) absolutely loved theirs, which is enough to get my rating up to 4 stars.